Personal Opinion: ScarNO for Ghost in the Shell!

WARNING: this is going to be ranty…so I apologise in advance.

So, news came about today that Scarlett Johansson has been cast as the iconic anime character Motoko Kusanagi from Ghost in the Shell.  The announcement doesn’t please me.  At all.

I don’t link the idea of a remake for Western audiences and I don’t agree with Scarlett Johansson’s casting.

I’ll tell you why.

file_124115_0_scar-ghost

After the whole Exodus casting saga, surely someone with half a brain cell should have taken more thought when casting one of the most iconic roles in anime.  But, casting gods think they are playing it safe with someone such as Johansson, who has already proved she is more than capable in an action role from Marvel films and last year’s Lucy.

But where is the fun in that?

In a time when up-and-coming Asian actors and actresses are making an impact, there is no shortage of young Japanese actresses Dreamworks could have signed up.  Babel and Kumiko: the Treasure Hunter‘s Rinko Kikuchi, Azumi‘s Aya Ueto or even Chiaki Kuriyama, famous for her roles in Battle Royale and Kill Bill’s Gogo, are some of the names that are known to Western audiences, especially those who are familiar with Japanese cinema.

But let’s face it – it’s all about the money.  With an ‘established’ actress with Johansson linked to the project, it will generate more interest / publicity, invoke lively debate on social media (the majority of initial thoughts on Twitter seem to be in the negative) and probably secure more financial support.  Additionally, it is probably easier to have a Western actress in the part rather than have a Japanese actress, who may have a wavering level of English.

But this is bollocks, especially with a key anime film.

However, to me, Johansson’s casting just feeds the idea that women in anime are there to represent sexualised objects.  Her figure will probably suit the character as shown in the films but the whole reason why Kusanagi is a strong character is she kicks ass and holds a position of authority.  Put simply, her strength is not based on looks, despite her frequent nakedness and this casting choice takes the focus away from this.

To cut a long rant short, this whole thing is uninspiring and lacks guts.

Note to casting directors – try harder. Much harder.

Thanks for reading.

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Personal Opinion: ScarNO for Ghost in the Shell!

  1. I understand the rant, and maybe I’ve become desensitised to white washing. I don’t know. I’m just happy Ghost in the Shell is getting attention from Hollywood, and we’ve seen what enough investment can do as long as the source material is treated properly (thinking of Sam Raimi’s Spiderman and the Avengers). I was furious with Tom Cruise being cast in Edge of Tomorrow, but eventually watched the movie and liked it. Emily Blunt was awesome, and hell, Tom Cruise is a good actor.
    I think Scarlett Johansson can pull this off – she’s got the makings of a real, badass, authoritative action hero. And I can believe that there would be cyborg ‘bodies’ styled like Johansson. So even though she’s not Japanese, maybe, hopefully, it will still be set in Japan and all the other characters will be Japanese?
    Maybe?

    1. I’m afraid Hollywood’s missed out on casting Chiaki Kuriyama. The anime of Ghost in the Shell has seen most characters as non ethnically Japanese, aside from their names, sadly. But in a movie a “face” known to westerners is the wrong choice. There’s a raft of really good female actors in Japan who could do it with ease. If they now cast John Hurt (good as he is) as Aramaki I will go and cry in a corner. Sadly as for being set in Japan? Good luck with that, it’ll make the whole thing look more obviously wrong if Tokyo is the setting. This is going to be a disaster for those of use who’ve read the manga or seen the anime.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s